Luci vs Stoic

Luci vs Stoic

Two apps for looking after your mind, coming at it from opposite ends. One is a journal first, with routines, meditation and an AI mentor. The other is a mood tracker first, built to show you what moves your mood. Let's go over the categories one by one to see which app is stronger where.

Updated November 18, 2026Compared: Luci 4.3.0 and Stoic 2026.23

Stoic is one of the best known journaling apps on the iPhone. It is made by Stoic app inc. in San Francisco, came out of Y Combinator in 2019, holds an App Store Editors' Choice badge and a 4.8 rating from tens of thousands of reviews, and its makers count over four million downloads. Despite the name, it is not only about Stoic philosophy. It is a daily routine for your mind: a morning check-in, an evening reflection, guided journals, quotes, meditation and breathing, and lately an AI mentor.

Luci overlaps with a good part of that. Both apps check in on your mood, both offer guided journaling with hundreds of prompts, and both keep your entries on your device without an account. The difference is the center of gravity. Stoic is built around writing and daily practice, and mood is one of the things it asks about. Luci is built around the mood and the day around it, the people, places, activities, sleep and weather, and reads them back to you in plain words.

So the real question is what you want to come back with: a richer daily practice, or a clearer picture of what shapes your mood. Each of the nine sections below looks at one category, gives both apps a fair hearing, and names a winner. The table at the foot collects the verdicts, and the conclusion says who should pick which.

The two apps in brief

Luci

Version 4.3.0

A mood tracker and guided journal that finds the patterns behind how you feel, and keeps everything on your device.

Luci logs a mood in one drag, lets you tag what was going on around it, and turns those entries into plain-language observations about what moves your mood. It doubles as a journal, with free writing and over 550 guided prompts. It is made by a small independent team, needs no account, and does its analysis on your phone.

Stoic

By Stoic app inc. · Version 2026.23

A polished journaling and wellbeing app with morning and evening routines, guided journals, meditation and an optional AI mentor.

Stoic, written both as Stoic and as stoic. by its makers, is made by Stoic app inc. in San Francisco and launched in 2019. Each day opens with a morning check-in and closes with an evening reflection, with mood check-ins, guided journals, daily prompts, quotes, affirmations, meditation and breathing exercises in between. Premium adds the full library, templates, iCloud sync and an app lock, and Premium + AI adds a mentor that replies to your entries. It runs on iPhone, iPad, Mac, Apple Watch, Apple Vision, the web and Android, and is available in eight languages.

Look and feel

How the app looks, how it feels to use, and how fast an entry is on a day when you have no patience for it.

Luci

The Luci mood entry screen with the slider mid-drag and influence chips below it

Luci opens on a slider. You drag it to where your mood sits, on a simple, standard or detailed scale shown as numbers, smileys or one of the illustrated icon packs, and that drag on its own is a complete entry. Everything else is optional: the activity, emotion, people and place chips underneath, a photo, a note. The screen is warm and unhurried, with a lot of white space, and the mood is always the first thing you see.

The cost of that depth is a busier interface once you start using it fully. Chips are grouped by kind, so the entry screen grows as you add things to track, and the statistics tab is a stack of cards that rewards a scroll. Luci is warm and tidy, but it does not have Stoic's sense of occasion.

Stoic

Stoic asking how you are feeling, with five faces from terrible to great

Stoic is carefully made, and Apple has featured it for years. It feels at home on an iPhone, with clean type and generous space, and the Today screen walks you through the day from the morning check-in to the evening reflection. A mood check-in is a 1 to 5 rating, as a slider or buttons, followed by tags. Quotes open full screen with their own themes and a focus mode.

It is also a lot to take in. The plus button alone offers a voice note, a photo, journaling suggestions, your templates, a mood check-in and an empty page, and it is not always clear which one you want. After an entry it asks every time whether you would like a breathing exercise. A button for the AI mentor, with its own name, is always on screen even though it only works with the AI subscription, and the paywall can appear when the app opens. There are no ads. Small details are inconsistent too: the calendar shows each mood as a filled circle rather than the face you picked.

WinnerLuci

Luci. Stoic is well crafted and feels native, but in use it is overwhelming: many ways to start an entry, a breathing prompt after every one, an AI button you cannot use without paying, and a paywall at launch. Luci's check-in is one drag, and it is calmer, though it also gets busier once you track a lot.

Insights

What you can learn from your own entries once you have a few weeks of them: charts, correlations, trends, and how clearly they are explained.

Luci

The Luci statistics screen with a trend line and ranked influences

This is the category Luci is built around. Every entry can carry a lot of information, from people, places, activities and emotions to sleep and the thoughts you had. Luci reads across all of your entries and says, in a sentence, what tracks with your better and worse days. It ranks each thing you tag by how far it shifts your average, so you can see that a particular meeting costs you more than a short night does. Each observation says how many entries it rests on, so five weeks of evidence carries more weight than five days.

Under the plain-language patterns are the charts: mood trend over any period, averages you can compare month against month, mood steadiness, time of day, day of the week, weather, location, steps and a word cloud drawn from your notes. The period in pixels view stretches from a single month to your whole history. It all runs on your phone, with no connection or account required, and the pattern discovery is part of the free app.

Stoic

The Stoic Trends screen with the top emotions of the year and the tags that lift and lower mood

Stoic's Trends screen charts your mood over time and lists the tags that come with your better days and the tags that come with your lower ones. It also charts sleep, mindful minutes and other data from Apple Health beside your mood. In our test all of this was there without Premium, and the journey view shows how your answers to the same prompt have changed.

The lists stop at the tag. There is no sense of how much each one moves your mood or how many entries a pattern rests on, and nothing that compares people, places or activities, because there is no way to track those. The deeper reading in words needs Premium + AI, where the mentor can look for patterns in your mood, focus and recurring themes, with a weekly usage limit.

WinnerLuci

Luci. Stoic's trends show which tags go with good and bad days, and charts your health data beside them. Luci ranks what moves your mood by size, says how much evidence each pattern rests on, covers far more of your day, and does it all on your phone for free.

Customization

What you can change: the mood scale, the things you track, the icons, the colors, the layout.

Luci

The Luci store of color themes and icon packs unlocked with Sparks

Luci lets you choose the mood scale itself: simple, standard or detailed, shown as numbers, Roman numerals, smileys, or one of five illustrated packs with cats, dogs, frogs, ghosts and glimmers. Everything you track is a chip you can add, rename, remove or pin, across activities, emotions, people, places, nutrition, physical state and thought patterns. The cards on the home screen and the statistics screen can be added, removed and reordered.

Looks are covered too. There are eight color themes, each in light and dark, and the extra themes and icon packs are unlocked with Sparks, which you earn simply by logging. The colors of the mood scale follow the theme you pick.

Stoic

The Stoic appearance settings with color theme, app icon and font

In Stoic, customization is mostly about your journal. You can write your own templates with your own prompts and structure, choose your routines and reminders, adjust the editor and pick themes for quotes. Each AI feature can be set to cloud, on device or off, and the mentor comes in ten personas, from supportive to deliberately blunt.

The tracking is close to fixed. You can choose whether a check-in asks about mood or energy, and whether it uses a slider or buttons, though in our test the choice did not seem to stick. The tags are general ones such as partner, party and cleaning, grouped by mood rather than by kind, and you cannot edit them or add your own.

WinnerLuci

Luci. Stoic lets you shape your journal with templates, routines and mentor personas, but what you track is largely fixed. Luci lets you choose the scale and the icons, edit and add every chip, and arrange the cards on screen.

Journaling

How good it is as a journal, for people who write more than a line. Formatting, prompts, photos, voice, and reading it back.

Luci

A guided journal prompt in Luci, part-way through an answer

Luci is a journal as much as a tracker. A note can use headings, bold and italics, and carry photos and voice notes. When the blank page is the obstacle, there are over 550 guided prompts across twenty topics, from stress and grief to money and motivation, each with optional guidance on how to approach it and a short tip drawn from cognitive behavioral therapy at the end of a session. You choose the topic, or take the daily prompt.

Because prompts repeat, Luci can show what you wrote last time the same question came round, which is the clearest evidence of change most people ever get. Your notes also feed the statistics: the word cloud and the journal moments card read them back to you. And on the days you want no prompt at all, the page is blank and yours.

Stoic

A Stoic journal entry with the menu for voice memos, photos, drawing and tags

Journaling is what Stoic does best. The morning check-in helps you prepare for the day and the evening reflection helps you close it. Guided journals cover gratitude, stress and anxiety, relationships, sleep, productivity and more, with prompts written with therapists and experts. There are daily prompts and weekly themes, journaling suggestions, your own templates, a blank page, and Therapy Notes for getting ready for a session. A mood check-in can lead into a prompt based on your mood and tags. Entries can carry photos, videos and voice notes.

Like Luci, Stoic can show how your answers to the same prompt change over time. With Premium + AI, a mentor replies to what you write, asks follow-up questions and can go deeper on an entry, and on recent iPhones some writing help runs on the device. The free tier has the daily prompts and basic guided journals, and most of the library is Premium.

WinnerStoic

Stoic. Both are strong journals with guided prompts and a record of how your answers change. Stoic adds morning and evening routines, templates, video and an AI mentor, though much of it is paid. Luci's prompts and voice notes are a close second, and more of them are free.

Other features

Everything outside the core loop: goals and habits, reminders, widgets, articles, achievements, watch apps.

Luci

Logging a mood in the Luci app on an Apple Watch

Outside the core loop Luci has home screen and lock screen widgets, an Apple Watch app with its own complications, reminders, and a set of mental health articles on topics like thinking traps and CBT that cite their sources at the foot of each piece. Logging earns Sparks, which unlock themes and icon packs, and there are achievements for keeping at it.

What Luci does not have is meditation, breathing exercises or a library of quotes and affirmations. It is a place to log and reflect rather than a practice to follow along with.

Stoic

The Stoic Quotes tab with a quote over a misty forest

Stoic surrounds the journal with a lot of practice. There are guided and unguided meditations, breathing exercises, daily quotes and affirmations, and themed events through the year. Streaks, badges and milestones keep you going, Stoic Shield blocks distracting apps, and there are widgets, Siri Shortcuts and an Apple Watch app.

Much of that library, along with streaks, badges and widgets, is part of Premium. The free tier has a limited selection of exercises.

WinnerStoic

Stoic. Meditation, breathing, quotes, affirmations, an app blocker and a watch app, against a watch app, articles and achievements. If you want a daily practice in one place, Stoic has far more of it.

Context and integrations

How much of the world around an entry the app can capture, by hand or from your phone: sleep, steps, weather, places, people, health data.

Luci

The Luci home screen with recent entries, their chips, and when you feel best

An entry in Luci can carry a lot of the world around it. People, places and activities are chips. Sleep and steps come in from Apple Health on iPhone once you allow it, so they sit beside a mood without being typed. A geotag attaches your location and the weather at the moment of writing, and a place can be pinned to a chip so it is selected automatically when you write from there. Nutrition, energy, rest and tension have their own sets, and so do recurring thought patterns like worry or self-judgement.

All of that becomes something the statistics can use. The steps card, the weather card, the location card and the people card each show how your mood moves with that input, and the impact ranking puts them all on one list. Health data read this way stays on your device. The limits are real, though. Luci reads sleep and steps only, and on Android the health connection is not currently available.

Stoic

The Stoic mood check-in with a list of feelings to choose from

Stoic's check-ins ask for a 1 to 5 rating and a few tags from its own list. From Apple Health it reads activity, mindful minutes and heart data, charts sleep, and saves your meditation and reading time as mindful minutes. On Android it works with Google Fit.

The rest is left to what you write. You cannot add tags for the people you were with, the places you went or your own activities, and there is no weather or location, so the context lives in your words rather than in data the trends can compare.

WinnerLuci

Luci. People, places, activities, sleep, steps, weather and location sit beside each mood as data the statistics can use. Stoic reads more health data than most journals, but leaves the rest of your day to your writing.

Privacy

Where your entries live, who can read them, whether an account is required, and how easily you can leave with your data.

Luci

Luci needs no account and no email address. Entries live on the device you wrote them on, and every statistic is calculated there too, so the app works in full with no connection. Sync is off until you turn it on. Switch it on and your journal follows you between phone, tablet and watch, encrypted, tied to an account you create at that point and not before. Nothing you write is used to train anything, and nothing is sent to a model to be read.

Leaving is a two-tap operation: export the lot as a readable PDF or as a backup file you can import again later. If you never turned sync on, there was never anything on our side to delete; if you did, there is a page in the footer that explains exactly how to remove it. Purchases go through Apple or Google, and crash reports are optional and carry no journal content.

Stoic

Stoic is also private by design. There is no account, entries live on your device, and with Premium they sync through your own iCloud rather than a Stoic server. Its App Store privacy label lists no data used to track you and none linked to you, only anonymous usage and diagnostics, which you can switch off. Face ID or a passcode can lock the app.

The AI features are where your words leave the device. They are off by default and part of the paid AI tier, and when you use them the entry is sent to an AI provider, OpenAI according to its help center, which may keep it for up to 30 days and does not train on it. Stoic itself keeps some limited, anonymized context to personalize replies. On recent iPhones you can keep AI on the device or switch it off entirely.

WinnerTie

A tie. Both need no account, keep entries on your device and treat sync as optional. Stoic leans on your own iCloud and has a very clean privacy label; Luci never sends your words to an AI model and analyzes everything on the phone. If you use Stoic without its cloud AI, the two are equally private.

Platforms

Where the app runs: iPhone, Android, iPad, watch, desktop, and whether your entries follow you between them.

Luci

iPhone, iPad, Apple Watch with its own app and complications, Mac with Apple silicon, Apple Vision, and Android. With sync on, one journal across all of them. Widgets on iOS and Android home screens, and the app in fourteen languages.

Stoic

iPhone, iPad, Mac, Apple Watch, Apple Vision, a web app and Android. Entries sync between Apple devices through iCloud, but iPhone and Android do not sync with each other. The Android app is newer and has largely caught up. Eight languages.

WinnerLuci

Luci. Both cover Apple devices well, watch included, and Stoic adds a web app. Luci syncs one journal between iPhone and Android, and comes in six more languages.

Pricing

What is free, what is paid, and roughly what the paid tier costs. Prices vary by country, so these are the options and a rough figure, not a quote.

Luci

Free, with no account, no ads and no time limit: mood logging, journaling, photos and voice notes, the statistics and pattern discovery, six of the twenty prompt topics, widgets and the watch app. Luci Premium adds sync across devices, the remaining guided prompt topics and the advanced statistics.

Premium is a subscription at roughly $6 a month or $35 a year, or a one-off lifetime purchase at roughly $200. A subscription bought on one platform works on the other once you sign in. There are also optional tips, which buy nothing and simply support a small team.

Stoic

Stoic is free to start, with no ads. In our test the free tier included mood check-ins and the trends, along with daily prompts, quotes, affirmations, basic guided journals and a few exercises. Most of the library, templates, iCloud sync, widgets and the app lock are part of Premium.

Premium is roughly $8 a month or $45 a year, shown as a discount on a full yearly price of about $96. Premium + AI, which adds the mentor, is roughly $15 a month or $100 a year, against a full price of about $180. Lifetime purchases were offered at roughly $230 for Premium and $450 with AI, down from about $350 and $800. Discounts appear to come and go, so what you see may differ.

WinnerLuci

Luci. Both have a usable free tier with no ads, but Luci's includes the full statistics and pattern discovery, and its Premium and lifetime prices are lower. Stoic's AI tier offers something Luci does not, at a much higher price.

The short version

Every category from the page above, in one table. Stars are our rating on a five-point scale; platforms and pricing are listed as they are.

CategoryLuciStoicWinner
Look and feelSlider entry, warm and roomy, busier once fully set upPolished and native, but complex, with a paywall at launch and constant promptsLuci
InsightsPlain-language patterns, ranked influences, trends, freeMood graph, uplifting and draining tags, Health charts; AI reading on Premium + AILuci
CustomizationThree scales, eight icon sets, eight themes, custom chips, movable cardsJournal templates, routines, quote themes, AI personas; fixed tagsLuci
JournalingRich text, photos, voice, 550+ prompts, compare past answersMorning and evening routines, guided journals, templates, video, AI mentorStoic
Other featuresWatch app, widgets, articles, achievements, SparksMeditation, breathing, quotes, app blocker, streaks, watch appStoic
Context and integrationsApple Health sleep and steps, weather, geotag, people, placesFixed tags; activity, heart, mindful minutes and sleep from Apple HealthLuci
PrivacyOn device, no account, on-device analysis, opt-in encrypted syncOn device, no account, iCloud sync, opt-in cloud AITie
PlatformsiOS, iPadOS, Android, Apple Watch, Mac, VisioniOS, iPadOS, Mac, Apple Watch, Vision, web, Android; no iPhone to Android syncLuci
PricingFree core, no ads; Premium ~$6/mo, ~$35/yr, ~$200 lifetimeFree start; Premium ~$8/mo, ~$45/yr; + AI ~$15/mo, ~$100/yr; lifetime from ~$230Luci

Conclusion

On the count, Luci takes six categories, Stoic takes two, and one is tied. Stoic wins the two it is built around: it is the richer daily practice, with routines, guided journals, meditation and an optional mentor. Luci is the clearer mirror. Its check-in is simpler, it tracks far more of your day, and it shows you what moves your mood, with more of that for free.

Where Luci is stronger

  • Insight in plain words. It explains what moves your mood, ranks it by size, and keeps pattern discovery free.
  • Context filled in for you. People, places, sleep, steps, weather and location sit beside a mood without being typed.
  • A generous free tier. Mood tracking, statistics, pattern discovery, photos and voice notes, with no ads.
  • Reach. The full app on Android, sync between iPhone and Android, and fourteen languages.

Where Stoic is stronger

  • Craft. Carefully made and at home on Apple devices, with a daily routine that has a sense of occasion.
  • Journaling as a practice. Morning and evening routines, guided journals, templates and Therapy Notes.
  • Wellbeing tools. Meditation, breathing, quotes, affirmations and an app blocker in the same place.
  • An AI mentor, for those who want one, that replies to your entries and talks through your patterns.

Choose Luci if

  • You want to know why some days are harder, and would like the app to explain what it found in plain words.
  • You want sleep, steps, weather and the people you were with in the picture without typing them in.
  • You want a simple check-in without a paywall or extra prompts along the way, and a lower price when you do pay.
  • You use Android, or switch between iPhone and Android, or want the app in a language Stoic does not offer.

Choose Stoic if

  • You want a daily routine for your mind, with a morning check-in and an evening reflection.
  • Writing is the main thing for you, and you would like many guided journals to choose from, even if the app takes some learning.
  • You want meditation and breathing exercises in the same app as your journal.
  • You would like an AI mentor to reply to what you write, and are happy to pay for it.

A fair way to decide is to ask what you want back from the time you spend. If the answer is “a calmer, more reflective routine”, Stoic is one of the best ways to build one. If the answer is “to understand what in my days is behind my moods”, Luci is built for that, and does it on your phone. Both are free to try, and a week of your own entries in each is a better test than any page.

How this comparison was made

Both apps were used side by side on the versions above, on an iPhone, with the free tier and the paid tier of each. Ratings are on the same five-point scale used across every comparison on this site. Stoic is a registered product of its maker and is not affiliated with Luci. Prices are rough US figures and change by country; check the store listing for yours.

Common questions

  • Is Stoic free?

    Stoic is free to start. In our test you could log moods and see the trends for free, along with daily prompts, quotes, basic guided journals and a few exercises. Most of the library, templates and iCloud sync are part of Premium, and the AI mentor needs Premium + AI. Luci is free to use with mood tracking, statistics, pattern discovery, photos and voice notes included, and an optional Premium tier for sync, the full set of prompt topics and the advanced statistics.

  • Is Stoic only about Stoic philosophy?

    No. Stoic draws on Stoic quotes and ideas, but most of the app is general journaling and wellbeing: check-ins, guided journals on everyday topics, meditation and breathing. You do not need to know anything about Stoicism to use it.

  • Does Luci have AI like Stoic?

    No, on purpose. Luci finds patterns with statistics that run on your phone, and nothing you write is sent to an AI model to be read. If an AI mentor that replies to your entries is what you are after, Stoic offers one in its paid AI tier.

  • Can I use Luci and Stoic together?

    You can, and they fit together better than most pairs. Some people keep Stoic for their morning and evening writing and meditation, and use Luci for quick mood check-ins through the day and the patterns behind them.

  • How current is this comparison?

    The date and version numbers at the top are the honest answer. Stoic ships often and added redesigned quotes, on-device AI and new AI settings in the last few weeks alone. If you spot something that is no longer true, we would rather hear about it than have you rely on it.

Try Luci for yourself

Free, works offline, no account needed. The fairest comparison is a week of your own entries.

Download Luci on the App StoreGet Luci on Google Play